TVNZ CloseUp
TVNZ Close Up current affairs program opting for plagiarism and gutter journalism to bolster sliding rankings.
Recently they were busted for stealing a story from an American network. As show presenter Mark Sainsbury puts it “A story we screened on Thursday night was inspired by a similar concept produced by our affiliate ABC America” (source). The reality is they copied the story word-for-word and shot-for-shot. Admittedly they did change out American made for New Zealand made as the story was about the buying habits of consumers and how well they support locally made products.
Not happy with such an embarrassing display of desperation to help rankings. They now admit they have no credible journalistic talent by scraping the gutters for “controversial” stories. Tonight these included a rehashed story about a dating website that encourages marriage infidelity and a story about the colour of the alternative English rugby jersey. Ninety percent or more of the comments they received on their Facebook fan page were fans voicing their disgust at the lack of noteworthy content on the show.
One may wonder if there is any other reason for the continued lack of decent stories given air time. We are being fed diet of the activities of the fringes of society which are always going to generate more discussion from the moderate majority and out-cries from the other extremes of society. Which in the short term may seem to bolster rankings – but will eventually cause most people to seek other channels for their news. Surely even TVNZ realizes this, so why do they persist down this road?
Perhaps they let a little too much slip tonight after the show when they bombarded their Facebook page with links to a sex therapist’s site who apparently featured on the show. This was obviously the actions of a program that has “sponsors” for their stories. It seems that in a tight economy our independent news reporters have stooped to selected stories based on the budgets of those seeking airtime. I haven’t looked into it but I suspect there are rules about the advertising that porn/sex sites can buy on TV especially during prime time. I also suspect that “editorial” content has more relaxed rules. Correct me if I am wrong but that is certainly how it appears to a bystander. Especially when comments were made to this end on the CloseUp fan page and shortly there after all posts and references to the sex sites and show clips featuring them were removed from the front page.
The other alternative is that CloseUp has decided to listen to the majority of their fans and clean up their act. Maybe Sainsbury has been convinced that his Jerry Springer/Jeremy Kyle act is taking a long walk off a short plank.
If I can plagiarize a Tui commercial “Yeah Right.”
But who knows, perhaps if the silent majority keep speaking out we may eventually convince them that there is a market for positive stories and genuine investigative journalism on TVNZ Close Up.
- Comments Off
-
August 3rd, 2011 by Admin
- Posted in General


